Portfolio Rebalancing in Volatile Markets

Portfolio Rebalancing Strategy in Volatile Markets

“The only constant is change.” This adage is nowhere more true than in the financial markets. Each day, thousands—sometimes millions—of buyers and sellers come together in the financial markets, and each transaction represents the participants’ agreement on the fair price of a particular asset at that moment in time, based on all the available information. The operation of this process, often described as the “efficient market,” is the reason why the market pricing of stocks, bonds, and other assets is constantly in motion.

What part does asset allocation play in portfolio management?

For the individual investor, of course, the constant movement of market pricing means that the assets in the portfolio are also in a constant state of motion, both individually and relative to each other. So, when an investor establishes a portfolio according to a desired asset allocation ratio—for example, the “60-40” mix of equities (60% stocks or stock mutual funds) and fixed income (40% bonds or bond funds) that is sometimes described as a “balanced” strategy for growth and income—the beginning asset allocation ratio begins to shift almost immediately, as the assets in the portfolio experience changes in value based on market price movement. While it is vital to get the initial asset allocation right (i.e., designing the portfolio to hold assets in proportions appropriate for the investor’s goals, needs, and ability to tolerate risk), it’s also important to understand that because of market price movement, maintaining proper asset allocation requires ongoing management, often in the form of rebalancing.

What is portfolio rebalancing strategy?

Rebalancing refers to the process of returning the portfolio’s asset allocation ratios to the desired range for the investor’s long-term strategy. Considering the 60-40 example above, suppose that over time, the fixed-income portion of the portfolio experiences an overall gain, so that its value now makes up 48% of the portfolio. To rebalance the portfolio, it may be necessary to sell some of the fixed-income assets and re-invest the proceeds in equities, bringing the portfolio back closer to its intended 60-40 range. By periodically rebalancing the portfolio, investors may be better positioned to achieve their intended goals over time.

How often to rebalance is a common rebalancing question. Research data presents a mixed picture, and there is academic debate between the “frequent” and “less frequent” camps. For the purposes of this piece, what is most important is that rebalancing occurs. Keep it simple and consider this exercise at least annually.

Why is rebalancing important during market volatility?

The purpose of rebalancing as a part of portfolio management is to maintain proper diversification as a way of managing risk. This can be especially important during volatile markets, whether the direction of the markets is up or down. On the other hand, f Failing to rebalance can, over time, expose the portfolio to greater risk, since “price drift” tends to reshape portfolio composition according to random market forces rather than the investor’s intended long-term strategy.

Periodic and systematic rebalancing is an important risk management tool because over the long term, history indicates that riskier asset classes, such as stocks, tend to go up in value at a faster rate than fixed-income assets, such as bonds. When this happens, the value of the stock portion begins to make up more and more of a portfolio’s value, increasingly raising the portfolio’s level of risk and increasing downside potential when markets become volatile. Periodically rebalancing, which returns the asset allocation back toward the originally targeted ratios, helps avoid letting the portfolio drift to a higher or lower risk allocation than intended.

Having an established rebalancing plan in place can also have emotional benefits for investors. While risk is always involved with participation in the financial markets, knowing that you have a long-term strategy in pace and keeping your portfolio “in-plan” through systematic rebalancing can help ease the urge to take drastic actions during volatile markets. Remember, emotion-driven responses to market movements are almost never correlated with improved portfolio performance over the long term. Instead, disciplined adherence to an appropriate investment plan typically helps investors reach many of their goals over time. While many aspects of the markets are beyond anyone’s control, the investor is able to exercise significant control over maintaining a broadly diversified portfolio with an asset allocation model appropriate for the investor’s situation. Rebalancing can help the investor counter the temptation to engage in negative financial behaviors, such as chasing market trends or panicked selling during a downturn.

What are the tax implications of rebalancing?

It’s important to understand that rebalancing in taxable brokerage accounts can have implications for the investor’s tax responsibilities. For example, if a particular asset increases in value, it may be necessary to sell a portion of it and reinvest in a different asset so as to bring the asset allocation ratio back toward the desired target range. However, when an asset is sold at a higher price than it was purchased at, a capital gain is created. In a taxable brokerage account, capital gains are taxed at either a short-term rate (for assets held less than a year) or a long-term rate (for assets held a year or more). Typically, the short-term rate is the same as the investor’s ordinary income rate, while the long-term rate is typically 0%, 15%, or 20%, depending on the investor’s total taxable income.

Sometimes, however, it is possible to take advantage of a strategy called tax-loss harvesting to manage an investor’s capital gains exposure. By selectively selling assets that are in a losing position, the investor may be able to use these losses to offset gains in other areas of the portfolio. In consultation with the investor’s financial and tax advisors, the investor may be able to use tax-loss harvesting to decrease the overall capital gains tax liability associated with portfolio rebalancing. In fact, periods of market volatility can sometimes present opportunities for tax-loss harvesting that the investor may be able to use advantageously as part of a portfolio rebalancing strategy.

It may be obvious that capital gains, either short- or long-term, are not an issue when they occur within a non-taxable account such as a Roth IRA, 401(k), or 403(b), or a tax-deferred account such as a traditional IRA, 401(k), or 403(b). And viewing your assets in their entirety (taxable and tax-deferred) is a vital piece of the rebalancing puzzle.

Rebalancing these accounts is thus important as they can be just as subject to “market drift” as taxable accounts.

We should also mention that it isn’t always necessary to sell assets in order to rebalance. Especially for investors who are still actively contributing to retirement accounts, it’s possible to achieve rebalancing by directing newly contributed cash toward assets presently below the target allocation ratio. So, for example, if the percentage of equities in an IRA have fallen below the target asset allocation model, a year’s contribution might be invested entirely in equity assets to bring the percentage closer to the desired level.

At JFS Wealth Advisors, we know that the performance of your portfolio is a matter of intense concern. Our fiduciary responsibility obliges us to work closely with clients to understand their needs, their goals, and their ability to tolerate market risk. By designing portfolios aligned with evidence-based principles, and by assisting clients with periodic review and rebalancing as needed, our goal is to help them benefit from long-term market trends as they pursue financial success. If you are wondering how evidence-based portfolio design and management could work for you, please let us know; we’d appreciate the opportunity to answer your questions.

How can I integrate philanthropy as part of my overall financial plan?

More Like This:

Get Started With
JFS Today

Subscribe to See More Articles Like This

Subscribe to Receive Our Regular Updates

Subscribe to Be Invited to Our Upcoming Webinars